Naomi, Sage – Author at Plaster & Disaster

By now our regular readers are very familiar with this type of post, in which we bring you all in on one of our favorite games: looking at stuff on craigslist and trying to figure out if it is awesome or terrible. We all know that the line between the two is really thin, and sometimes we all need a little help figuring out where something falls!

We’ve played this game before (check out some past posts here, here, and the original here) and it doesn’t get old. (At least not for us, tell us if it does for you :)) That’s because there is ALWAYS more stuff on craigslist for creative people to buy, fix-up… or mock. Which would you do to the pieces below?

First up, is this rather extraordinary chair. Extraordinary, as in, this chair is at no risk of being called ordinary.

$300 is a little much for a chair, but then again, you don’t see this kind of chair every day, so it’s hard to get a read on the market price point. And, surprisingly, it actually looks like it would be pretty comfortable.

But what kind of room could hold up to this statement piece? Would it make the room awesome, or bring it all spiraling down?

Next, what about this retro dining set?

Retro is always in, but is this particular color too far out?

$200 is a good price for a table and chair set, but is that worth sitting on chairs that look like lettuce wrapped in twine?

While we’re on the topic of retro furniture, how about this set?

Okay yes it would need to be reupholstered, but for two danish chairs and a sofa, we’re tempted. The frames look pretty darn nice.

But can you see past the plaid?

We put a lot of wicker/rattan items in this series, because apparently we just can’t make up our minds about it. Is it awesome or terrible? Maybe it depends. What about in throne form?

It’s pricey, but would it make an awesome statement piece for an eclectic/boho sun room type space?

Honorable Mentions:

Then, of course, there are the things we find on craigslist that we don’t have to ask whether they are awesome or terrible. For the things below, it’s pretty clear where they fall. But they are still “great” enough that we wanted to share them with you!

Take this shabby chic… modernist… industrial… console.

Who ever thought that those three things should go together? They’re all complete opposites. Not sure how 3 different things can all be opposite each other, but in this case, it is somehow true.

And then we also had to show you this post, which we just couldn’t not click when we saw it:

What exactly makes an end table “match” a print?

They’re all maps, obviously!

It’s like an instantly coordinated room!

Finally, a post that is in our honorable mentions not because it is clearly terrible, but because it is clearly AWESOME:

We’ve agreed to go in on these alpacas together. Sage’s new planter will be a watering trough and the blog will henceforth be re-named to Disaster and Alpac-er. We do feel kind of bad for this guy who has to get rid of his best friends…but what a steal!

Stay tuned for more on our adventures as first time ~~home~~ alpaca owners!

(Also a heads up, we’re taking Monday off of posting for Labor Day. If you want to hear more about what the holiday is all about besides the end to wearing white pants, be sure to check out our post from last year. We’ll be back next Wednesday!)

As you well know if you’ve been reading this blog for any amount of time, a lot went into our kitchen renovation. Our list of projects was loooong, and even though it took us almost 18 months, we finally got through it…almost. Can you spot the one that remained incomplete?

That’s right, I still was on the hunt for stained glass for our big picture window. It’s the only window in the kitchen (thank goodness we opened things up to the sunroom!) so we treasure the light it lets in, but the window also opens right up onto our neighbor’s main door, living room, and kitchen (hard to fully appreciate because of course it’s difficult to photograph without it getting totally blown out).

Because of our house’s layout, that means that our neighbors can see us whenever we’re walking in and out of our bedroom, bathroom, kitchen, and living room — kind of a lot of our house! That means that a lot of the time, we keep the blinds closed, which isn’t very nice looking from the outside or inside.

I thought about privacy blinds that would still let light in, but from almost Day 1 of buying the house I was pining for a big stained glass panel that we could hang to provide privacy while also continuing to let light in and add color and interest to our home (which is otherwise not the most architecturally exciting space). I loved the architecture of our old apartment (a classic Somerville triple-decker) and we had a stained glass window in our living room like so many houses of that style (of which I sadly appear to have zero good photos but have many good memories). The idea of bringing some of that style into this home was very appealing.

Of course I knew that it might take a very long time to find a piece of stained glass that was the right style, size, and price point. I was willing to splurge a little (knowing I might need to spend $500-$600 to get something decent that was large enough), but if I was going to spend that much then the style and size needed to be perfect.

For literally years I kept my eyes open on trips to architectural salvage stores and flea markets, and checked craigslist regularly. The closest I came was this past spring at Brimfield, when I came across I few pieces I liked. I loved the style of these, but the dimensions weren’t right and they were too clear to provide much privacy:

And this one was okay but it was a little bit shorter than I wanted and I wasn’t totally sold on the style.

Since I knew it might take me awhile to find the right thing, I stopped thinking about this as an integral part of my kitchen makeover, as I wanted to be able to call that DONE even if I was still on the hunt for the right stained glass. Fortunately, the purpose of this post is to announce (a mere 600 words in) that I finally found it!

One day recently I was checking craigslist, and came across this posting:

The dimensions were right (though on the smaller end of the range I’d identified as workable), the price was most definitely right, and I really liked the style — it’s what the stained glass windows in the Boston Area typically look like, so it felt somehow authentic to our space even though it’s not our specific house’s style. I immediately sent an email to see if it was still available, it was, and I trekked up to near the New Hampshire border to pick it up.

The thing about stained glass is that it looks downright depressing when it’s not in front of the light…especially because it was in dire need of scraping and new paint.

But I knew from looking at it in the light that it would be great for the space with a little TLC.

The first thing I did was test the paint for lead. The owner wasn’t sure quite what time period it was from, but suspected 60s or 70s — meaning it definitely could have lead paint. Rather than sending off a sample for analysis, I used a well-reviewed self-tester kit that I got from Amazon (affiliate link – read our policies).

The thing to know about this kit is that you can get a false positive — that is, if it comes back negative then you can be confident there’s no lead, but if it comes back positive it’s possible that there isn’t really lead. I was willing to take this chance because I knew that it would be safe if it was negative, and if it was positive then I’d just need to send a sample out for more testing which is the only alternative I would have had to self testing in the first place.

The test was quite easy, I just followed the directions and used swabs to test both sides of the window (since the paint was different on each side).

I was quite happy when it all came back negative, which meant I could scrape and repaint it myself!

The back especially was in really rough shape, which I wasn’t too concerned about since this will be facing out and really not seen that well (since it won’t actually be on the exterior of our house, it will be hanging in front of our existing windows). I used a screwdriver to remove loose paint and molding.

If we were installing this as an actual window, I would probably need to get the frame completely redone because it was really coming apart in places, but for hanging it decoratively that wasn’t an issue. I still might do that someday, but for now it’s okay.

Then I painstakingly applied a coat of primer and two coats of white paint to both sides. It took a good long while…. Hanging it was super easy, I just used some S hooks and chain I bought at Home Depot; I cut the chain to length using my dremel.

And here it is!

I love how it looks in the space, and it gives us the privacy we were looking for without blocking much light. Here’s what you see from the hallway outside our bedroom now, instead of our neighbor’s living room:

Much better! And I love how it adds a little interest to the outer wall of the kitchen, which before was feeling a little dull compared to the rest of the newly renovated space.

Notice Murphy’s ghostly figure enjoying it, thanks to my long exposure.

Here’s another one for you Murphy lovers:

So there you have it — while we’ll always keep puttering in the kitchen, I think the long list of projects we set out to accomplish way back in January 2016 is finally finished!