As I shared a few weeks ago, I laid down a new VCT tile floor on top of our old asbestos floor.
Encapsulating it like this is usually the safest option as long as the asbestos tile isn’t breaking or peeling up, which we were told by several professionals that we had come and take a look at the space.
But taking a step back, why did we get launched on this floor improvement project right now, when we have so many other things in the house we want to work on? We had known for a long time that the floors were asbestos, but it never felt pressing to deal with because they were in good condition (ie not breaking, which is what actually releases asbestos into the air). However, a few months ago I discovered some areas in other parts of the basement where the floors had begun to break, primarily around the edges.
This hazard was mostly hidden behind things that our seller left behind like our downstairs fridge, which is why it took us awhile to notice — it was only visible when I really started poking around the darkest corners of the basement. However, it was an immediate flag that we needed to get professionals involved, so I found a few asbestos removal companies that were well-reviewed on Angie’s List and had them out to take a look.
Both companies confirmed that it would be fine to just remove the broken sections rather than the full floor and then put a new floor over it. We obviously wanted to get the broken sections removed as quickly as possible, and both companies gave pretty similar estimates: $300-$400, since it was just very small sections and wouldn’t require a massive disposal effort.
Both companies were well-reviewed and would take all the standard precautions when removing the tile (sealing off the space, wetting down the tiles during removal, cleaning the air after removal), so I ended up going with the company that could do it the soonest. They were out the very next week, and in the span of a morning we want from scary asbestos shards to clean edges:
The black sections are where they removed broken and loose tiles, and leaving in place any surrounding tiles that were totally intact and secure.
It was a big relief to get the issue taken care of, but of course this isn’t a viable long term look for the space. Plus if we left the floor exposed, over time more pieces would start to break because it’s just a very old floor.
That’s when I decided to take on tiling in one corner, to see if it was a viable approach for the full basement. That undertaking convinced me of two things: 1) This was definitely the way to go, since it was relatively inexpensive, durable, and made a huge aesthetic improvement, and 2) I did not feel like doing the rest of the basement myself. I had done the very smallest quadrant, and doing the rest of the basement would require a ton of prep work, carrying incredibly heavy boxes of tile/bags of leveler/buckets of adhesive, and crawling around on my hands and knees for days.
The annoying thing about having a job is that I spend a lot of my time doing it and don’t have a ton of free time. The great thing about having a job is that I earn money that I can then spend on hiring professionals to do home projects that I either don’t have the technical skills to do at all or very well, or that I just plain don’t want to spend my time doing. The floor struck me as a little bit of both, since the corner I did myself is fine but I think a professional would get a much smoother finished result that may be more durable.
We ended up finding someone to do the work pretty soon, and I’ll write a whole separate post about how I picked someone to do it, how much it cost, and how it turned out. In the meantime, I’ll just share the prep work we did, since we needed to clear out the basement to make it possible to lay a new floor and I’m pretty impressed with our handiwork.
We agreed with the floor guy that we would move all the small stuff and he’d take care of the big pieces and work in a few chunks since it wasn’t possible to get everything totally out of the basement at once. Sam and I spent Saturday afternoon working on it, and I’m pretty impressed with how much we were able to cram into the one corner with the finished floor. As you’ll recall, our basement normally has a fair amount of stuff in it:
We got all the smaller pieces of furniture, tools, scrap wood, and exercise equipment into just one corner:
Which leaves the rest of the space fairly open:
We also took off the back of the workbench so that it will be easier for the floor guy to move it, since it’s a big heavy piece:
He’ll only have to move the two work benches (which are totally cleared of tools), washer, dryer, fridge, and some of our exercise equipment. We also cleared out the closets, and took the closet doors off so that when he adds the tile on top of the existing floor he doesn’t have to deal with the closet doors getting stuck on the new higher floor. I’ll cut them down and rehang them once the floor is in.
With all that work done, here’s hoping we have a brand new floor soon!