Naomi, Sage – Author at Plaster & Disaster

Welcome to another Craigslist: Awesome or Terrible post! This is when we invite you in one of our favorite games: deciding whether what we see for sale on craigslist is amazing or horrible.

Long-time readers know the drill by now. In the same way that our favorite stories take familiar elements and make them exciting again with new twists or ideas, we look for things that are novel and interesting for our homes. But we need a reasonable mix of the familiar and the strange or things can get weird real fast. The line between decor that is new and cool and decor that is truly awful is a thin one, and craigslist, as a comprehensive catalog of humanity’s wide ranging taste, is the perfect showcase for that.

And sometimes you just need a gut-check from a friend… or tons of friends on the internet… to help you tell where on that line it falls.

So let’s get to the game!

First up, we have this ornate carved bench, at what is actually not a crazy-unreasonable price for the style.

It looks well done, but is it overdone? Would it only look good in a medieval mansion, or could a regular house pull this off?

Our first thought when we look at something “interesting” on craigslist is usually: could Emily Henderson pull this off? The answer is usually yes, because she can pull off most things. Then we consider the fact that most people are not Emily Henderson and probably can’t pull off nearly half of the things that she does. Try applying that thought process to this little side table:

Is it adorable, spacey and retro, or just weird? Does the green marble ruin what would otherwise be a nice shape? Emily Henderson could make it look great for sure – but could you?

The fact that wicker/rattan show up in almost all of our “awesome or terrible” posts really speaks to the extreme ambiguity of those decor elements. They can go so hard in either direction: boho or frumpy, delightfully quirky or all over the place.

This time, we have two contenders in this category. First, consider this little table:

The shape is kind of nice, and it could be sweet on a porch or causal living room… or it could look like grandma’s house. What do you think?

OK, whether that was your style or not, how about this rattan loveseat, which is retro but somehow also feels a little more modern:

Is it cool and sculptural, or does it only look that way because it is missing cushions? Would it only be comfortable if you added so much padding that it would look frumpy?

Finally, we feel similarly ambiguous about armchairs in this style. Are they sweet or are they old-fashioned? Can they even be comfortable? This seems like a pretty good specimen of the type, so let’s put it to a vote:

Honorable and Dishonorable Mentions

And to close us out, here are a few gems that we found in the hunt for items for this post that we wanted to share with you.

In the ‘honorable’ category, a shout-out to this guy who took the time to beautifully arrange spare plumbing parts all in the hopes of selling them for $1:

We also didn’t want to put this up for a vote given that it is someone’s personal DIY project, but did want to share this makeover of an old ironing board into a sofa table:

Whatever you think of the style (it probably wouldn’t fit in our houses) the finish looks beautiful and well done, and it’s a fun idea.

In the less honorable category, check out these very expensive shoe side tables (not a typo):

That’s more than we’d pay for regular shoes that we could actually wear.

This creative spelling of “chair” also caught our eye:

Although the chair itself actually looks pretty useful and like a good deal.

Finally, the question of “why on earth is this listed for sale on craigslist?” is obviously, “well, where else could you sell it?”

Thanks for reading and playing along with us!

It’s basically the winter holidays, isn’t it? Terrifying. We don’t tend to do a lot of holiday type content on this blog (beyond once giving you a real look at what our houses look like around the holidays). But there is one spot where we think we an add some value: good gift ideas for your DIYer loved ones. We already have most of these, so we swear this is (mostly) not an elaborate phishing ploy.

The ideas we provide below cover a pretty wide range of price points depending on how much you’re looking to spend. Note that all the product links in this post are affiliate links. For more information on this, please check out our policies.

DIYer Gift Idea #1: A “Specialty Tool” That’s Actually The Most Useful Thing Ever

If your friend is an avid DIYer, chances are they already have all the basics. However, there are a few additional tools that we’ve both found ourselves using all the time that we might never have bought ourselves if they hadn’t been gifted to us by an encouraging friend or relative. Even though they perform some pretty specific functions, it turns out we use these items widely in our projects and they’re incredibly easy and accessible.

Kreg Jig

A kreg jig is essentially a specialty attachment for a power drill that allows you to drill pocket holes. You might not realize at first why pocket holes are so handy, but once you have a kreg jig you’ll find yourself using them constantly.

Pocket holes allow you to join two pieces of wood that would be difficult to join otherwise — like if both pieces are too wide/thick to drill in from the outer edge, or if you don’t want a screw showing on the outside. We’ve used a kreg jig on building projects like cabinets and furniture, and the great thing is that if you know how to use a drill, you can use a kreg jig. This kit for ~$80 has everything you need to get started.

Dremel rotary tool

Another tool we wouldn’t necessarily have bought for ourselves is a dremel rotary tool, which is a handheld device that spins a wheel around really quickly — quickly enough that the wheel can buff, grind, and cut things depending on what attachment you use.

Sage was gifted a dremel early in her DIYing career, and Naomi got hers from Brad for the holidays last year. We’ve used them for really dumb things like cutting the tops off of spoons to make an ugly mirror, but also to do really helpful things like sanding down sharp metal edges on Sage’s coffee table and trimming down the grates that finally solved Naomi’s infamous grate disaster. Naomi has this model, which right now is available for less than $40 including a variety of attachments.

Locking pliers

One disadvantage of DIY is that you’re often teaching yourself — which means you might not know about awesome tools that make life so much easier. A good friend can introduce you to seemingly-simple things like locking pliers (these ones are $23):

You might be like, “but I already have pliers,” and then once these were foisted upon gifted to you, you wouldn’t know how you’ve been living without them. Ever have a stripped screw, or something screwed on so tight you couldn’t pry it loose? Locking pliers let you clamp tightly around the item (more than you could ever do by hand with regular pliers) and then rotate it free.

DIYer Gift Idea #2: A Tool Just Outside of Their Comfort Zone

The best gift that you can get your DIYer friend is the confidence to master a new tool that will allow them to take on new types of projects. Trite? Yes, extremely, but also true. It can be intimidating to “go to the next level” with a bigger tool, but when someone else buys it for you and encourages you to use it, it is a lot easier. Just be prepared to suffer absurd levels of mansplaining and condescension when you go to the home improvement store to procure said gift….

A Jig Saw

This is one of the most accessible power saws, so if you have a friend who likes crafts but hasn’t taken on bigger projects yet and is sick of cutting things with a handheld saw, this would be an ideal gift. Beyond simple cuts, it can do some pretty intense projects (like when Sage used hers to cut metal bars to build a coffee table base). We each recommend the ones that we have: Naomi’s is a slightly older version of this one by Porter-Cable (~$60) and Sage’s is an older Ryobi model (~$50).

A Circular Saw

A gift from a friend can empower you to try something new, or at the very least it can make you feel pressure to try something you’d otherwise be terrified of so as not to hurt your friend’s feelings. This is how Naomi’s adventures with the circular saw first began with a gift from Sage a few years ago, and now Naomi uses it in basically every project.

Circular saws can be intimidating because they are loud and the blade is big, but they are also incredibly versatile and useful. Whether you use it to cut large surfaces that would be difficult to cut otherwise — like plywood and counters — or it’s your go-to saw for cuts big and small, a circular saw is worth learning to use.

Naomi has this one, available for ~$70. And if you’re going to use one often, you can definitely save yourself some time by making a saw guide and setting up a cutting station if you have the space.

Air Compressor & Nail Gun

For some reason anything pneumatic (ie requiring pressurized air from an air compressor) has always seemed pretty intimidating. Thus Sage was thrilled when Naomi got her an incredible three-tool combo kit with an air compressor and three different sizes of pressurized nail/staple guns.

Working with pressurized air is not actually very hard, and it makes work that would otherwise be very laborious (hammering nails) so quick and satisfying. Sage used hers extensively in her kitchen renovation to add new trim/crown molding and attach facing to new cabinets, and this summer on some outdoor projects like her new trellis.

DIYer Gift Idea #3: Good Quality Versions of Things They Use All The Time

If your friend already has everything or giving power tools isn’t up your alley, another option is to gift high quality versions of things they already own. So many DIYers start out with entry-level items and then don’t invest in the higher quality alternatives that really do make a difference.

Nice Clamps

Last year for the Winter Holidays, Sage’s dad gave her a set of a bunch of different clamps — and it was pretty much the best thing ever. How else could she have created that Frankensteined extra-wide threshold for the transition between her kitchen and sun room?

If you think they already have good quality clamps, you can also invest in an extra large pair which essentially substitute for extra hands when doing a large project.

Yes nice clamps might not seem that exciting at face value, but they are a crucial staple when it comes to building things and it makes a huge difference to have a complete set of different sizes and options.

High Quality Paint Brushes

Nice paintbrushes really make a difference when it comes to ease of use and results. There is nothing worse than a crappy brush that leaves loose bristles or visible brush strokes in your fresh paint job. Good brushes are expensive, though, and no matter how much you care for them, eventually they get worn out (especially if you’re working with stains and oil-based paints). If someone got us a pack of brushes — like this one from Purdy — as a gift (HINT HINT HINT), we’d be pretty darn pleased.

Drill Bit Sets

If your friend is a DIYer, chances are they use their drill bits constantly. As you’d expect, bits get dull over time — especially if you’re drilling into walls and other tough materials — and even break (if you’ve ever broken a drill bit off inside of a project, you’ll know that locking pliers are a lifesaver!).

You can’t go wrong gifting a nice set of bits, which are also compact and pretty affordable — this black oxide set of 20 bits from DeWalt runs about $28. Every time your friend picks up their drill they’ll think of you and be grateful that they’re not still using the same set of drill bits they’ve had for the last 10+ years.

So there you have it, those are a few ideas we have for your DIY-loving friends and family. And we’d love to hear from you: what are the best DIYing gifts you’ve received and/or given?