So this time around, our bedroom was one of the first rooms we worked on, about a month into owning the home.
Here’s the bedroom our first night in the house. Don’t judge, it was a stressful time.
And here it is for the first month we were in the house:
Yeah, this is pretty sad looking. This is me being vulnerable and honest with you guys, I do not like to show my home looking like this. The walls were a nondescript cream color, with wood window casings, doors, crown molding, and very beat up base boards. There were a number of holes in the walls, plus unsanded spackle from where the seller had done about 50% of the work to patch holes. And since we knew we wanted to paint, we didn’t want to spend time putting up mirrors, artwork, curtains, etc in the meantime — so our bedroom was in a state of bland limbo.
Though the room is relatively small and we have fairly low ceilings, we decided to go with a dark color — we’ve always liked to think of our bedroom as a little cave-like, a cozy place where we can retreat and sleep and relax. I picked out Black Pepper by Benjamin Moore, and had it color-matched to Olympic ONE paint. We also bought some tinted primer because we thought it would allow us to use only one coat of paint (paint is more expensive than primer), but when we opened it up it wasn’t as dark as I’d hoped (I think partially because it wasn’t freshly mixed since it took us a month to get around to the project after buying the paint) so we just decided to skip the primer. We ended up only needing one coat anyway, the coverage was so rich.
First I spent a day painting the window casings and doors white. It seems like this shouldn’t take so long, but it really does. I had to do one coat of primer and then two coats of white paint to cover up the original wood underneath. Before anyone panics about painting wood, it was not in good condition, and it looks much better painted. Plus it’s our house, and I want white trim. So there. ☺
I also spent time fixing and patching some holes in the walls — our seller damaged the walls in a few places by hanging artwork and such, so I needed to patch that up. In one place there were metal pieces that I couldn’t remove protruding from giant holes, so I use my dremel to trim them down and then I spackled the holes.
- The challenge
- Nothing a dremel can’t handle
- And then spackle to fill the hole (this is actually wood filler because I was out of spackle, but spackle would be better)
The next day, we were ready to paint. Sam rolled the walls, while I painted around the floor, ceiling, and windows with an angled brush. The detailed work takes so so so long, much longer than rolling. That’s the curse of having better fine motor skills than my lovely husband, I suppose. I painted both the crown molding and the baseboards the same colors as the walls, because I thought it would help make the walls seem a little taller if they weren’t sandwiched between trim on the top and bottom (the ceilings are only 7.5 feet).
I knew we had a winning combination when I saw how the dark walls looked with the white trim:
Once the paint dried, I tackled some decorating — adding art, mirrors, and curtains, plus moving in the new side table I bought at a yard sale the previous weekend to serve as a bedside table. I’m so pleased with it — it’s the same height as the other bedside table, and they relate so much better to each other because they’re both wood.
Without further ado, here’s where we are now:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/adbb8/adbb8efe3a75688f423349308d290dea6e0dc373" alt="Moody and dark bedroom -- Plaster & Disaster"
The lamps, throw pillows, and curtains are all DIY projects from our apartment-dwelling days (one of the lamps was Sam’s when we started dating, the other I found in a thrift store years later and discovered it was an exact match, then I painted them both white; the curtains I made out of a shower curtain from Target).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a8112/a8112f6d94ed37ed8ae49db0b31336eb08a88962" alt="Moody and dark bedroom -- Plaster & Disaster"
The mirror I got off of craigslist and painted white years ago, and the jewelry bust is made of foamcore — one of my first DIY projects ever. The jewelry armoire was my first furniture painting project — it used to be brown laminate. The inside is lined with patterned green contact paper.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2857a/2857aea8b307b79d4a13d8f92f9eff2e1e2347f1" alt="DIY sunburst mirror -- Plaster & Disaster"
The sunburst mirror is a DIY, made out of paint stirrers (inspired by Centsational Girl); in the vase are faux craspedia (billy balls) that I made out of felt roving; the full-length mirror was left behind by the seller on the back of the closet door, and I want to make a wooden frame for it to add some heft.
It’s a huge change, right?!? We’re pretty darn pleased. We love the paint — it’s a dark gray, but it reads deep blue in some lights. It feels so much more sophisticated now, but also calm and cozy. I don’t know if I would have thought a room could be both “sophisticated” and “cave-like,” but this room has convinced me. And I love the relatively simple decor.
Here are a few of my favorite details:
My dresser and jewelry armoire, where I finally got my jewelry set up. I find that I never wear jewelry unless I have it out and easily accessible.
In our apartment I had an earring holder that I made out of an old bulletin board, but I wanted to keep the wall next to the mirror uncluttered so I grabbed an earring tree at Michael’s. The wooden box that says “Sage” is something my mom came across and gave to me. Currently it’s hiding my deoderant…now you know all my secrets. Also, in all our moving, our two dressers definitely got a bit beat up. They’re family pieces, and I really want to do some simple restoration work on them. Naomi has had good luck with Howard restor-a-finish products, so maybe I’ll give that a try and we can report back.
Another detail I like is the hook I added next to Sam’s side of the bed, where he can hang his robe. It’s tucked away from view when you enter the room, but within easy reach for those frigid and dark New England mornings when getting out of bed is torture.
And here’s a close up of the art behind the bed:
This is what we have engraved in our wedding rings: “We finish each other’s” in Sam’s, and “sandwiches” in mine. It’s a quote from Arrested Development (I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: Frozen stole this from Arrested Development, and it’s not the only thing they lifted), which is one of our favorite shows.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4ce57/4ce57b4915665c6bbea049406229216669a3426b" alt="Arrested Development and Frozen"
The writers of Frozen claim to have never seen the show and instead say: “Sandwiches are a very big part of our writing experience. […] We were always eating bagels when I was writing these lyrics.” Sure…
To make the prints, I grabbed two frames from Michael’s in a two-for-one sale, and also got some posterboard that I cut to the size of each frame. Then I printed out the text on some nice paper I had left over from wedding projects, and used double-sided tape to stick the printouts in the middle of each piece of poster board. (Someday soon I will make actual mats for them using the mat-cutting tools I recently bought, but this will do for now.) Then I slipped them into the frames and hung them up. Simple as that. I’m a big fan — they’re sweet because they have meaning for us, but not overly romantic which just isn’t our style and also would feel kind of out of place in this bedroom which seems to have a more masculine aesthetic with the dark colors and wood furniture.
So that’s it! It really has come a long way. Just a quick reminder of the before and after:
With so much more work to do on the house, it’s nice to go to bed every night in a space that we love and that feels complete. Lesson learned, bedroom makeover should always be near the top of the to-do list. Plus I love the fact that we totally made over the room while relying 90% on things we already owned, including so many DIY pieces — the only new things were the yard sale side table ($10), art behind the bed ($12 for frames), the earring tree ($12), and of course the paint.
(FEATURED at AKA Design! – and sharing at Think and Make Thursdays and Remodelaholic)
Now all you need is a turquoise and tangerine quilt :-o.
We’re ready for it, but being patient 🙂
Love the color and really made a difference to paint out the moldings at ceiling & baseboard…good call!
Thanks so much, Mary Ann! It’s great when a good design decision is also the easier path 🙂 Thanks for reading!
I never would have thought to paint the baseboards the same color as the walls. It looks awesome and it really does elongate the walls. We have 8′ ceilings as well (no crown molding) but I painted all of our baseboards white. I also like the bold color you chose. I did the same in both of our bedrooms because I think it makes a room cozier and your bedrooms should be cozy. Great job!
Thanks Rosy! The contrast of white baseboards on dark walls looks great in your home tour. I’m not going to lie, the idea for my decision came to me after I spent an entire day painting the trim around the windows and doors white and was looking for an excuse to avoid doing the baseboards and crown molding too 🙂 But I had a suspicion it would look good — the doors go right up to the ceiling almost, and I thought would look so crunched between top and bottom trim. 7.5′ is so low!
Thank you for visiting my blog! I’ve been there where taking a “shortcut” turns out to look pretty darn good.
I enjoyed looking at your room makeovers thus far!
It’s a total myth that dark colors make a room look smaller! First thing you learn in art/interior design class is that dark colors recede and light come forward so why wouldn’t dark paint paint the walls recede and light come forward ?!? I think the right duvet print pulling it all together, folded at the foot of the bed with solid sheets/blankets and darker solid bed skirt is going to complete the scheme beautifully. I agree with an early response that something in the orange family is going to really pull the orangey brown wood tones into the room. You already know that Naomi is a fantastic fabric designer with an online source so you two could create the fabric and an duvet cover is just a giant pillow slip: four seems and some velcro or giant buttons for accent. I’m loving your blog…reminds me how much can be done with so little if you have some imagination!
Thanks so much, Kathryn! We’re so glad to have you as a reader, and thrilled we’re keeping you entertained so far. I love the idea of sewing a custom duvet cover — I’ve sewn one before, and found it quite easy as you suggested even as a pretty novice sewer. The earlier comment was in reference to a quilt that my mom, who is a talented quiltmaker, is making us, so I’m really looking forward to adding that to the room — I think the orange will add a great splash of color. But you’ve gotten me thinking about the possibilities with custom designing a fabric. With more bedrooms to tackle, I’ll add that to the list of promising projects!
WOW your rooms looks fanastic, amazing what a difference a new layer of paint makes isn’t it. I love your prints and those pretty cushions too!
Thanks so much, Vicki! Paint is such an incredible DIY tool — and good thing, because pretty much every room in my house needs it 🙂
WOOHOO! Thank you girls for joining my Cheap-o Room Challenge! So far you wear the crown with this gem! The crown is probably made of stuff I found in the trash, but is now clean and looks really awesome! We’ll see if anyone challenges you…It’ll be tough to beat $75! XOXO!
Erica
http://onblissstreet.blogspot.com/2015/03/cheap-o-room-upgrade-challenge-are-you.html
That crown sounds right up my alley 🙂 Thanks Erica!
BTW- Pinned to my Challenge Board and page! I knew there were more people enraged about Frozen stealing that line! I looked around the theater to see the other AD fans in fits of rage, but alas, it was only little girls and their popcorn eating parents… We should start a support group.
Glad to have found a kindred AD spirit! My husband and I watched Frozen at home, and when it happened just looked at each other with incredulity! Makes my blood boil to think there are hordes of children out there giving credit to Disney for AD’s genius, but I’m probably fixating on it too much 🙂
I love your room girls. Grey is so in now and if I hadn’t recently bought a cinamon coloured sofa my living room would be done in neutral greys. I am doing my foyer in the Cheap-o-challenge too. It’s so much fun having a project.
Well done.
Thanks so much, Lori! Can’t wait to see your finished result!
Hi! I found your blog through Apartment Therapy; I am in LOVE with this project, and this blog in general.
What color paint did you use for the walls and trim? It is absolutely gorgeous.
Nvmd! Found your pallet post! 🙂
So glad you found the color info, and thanks for your kinds words about the bedroom and Plaster & Disaster! So glad you found us, and I hope you enjoy continuing to poke around! 🙂